Mills v. New York City: What the Ruling Means for NYC Gun Owners
NYC’s one-handgun carry rule and 90-day acquisition limit still apply after Mills, but the Second Circuit ruled that the City must justify those limits and a former listing cap under Bruen’s history-and-tradition test.
By Peter Ticali · NY Safe Inc.
NRA Benefactor Life Member · NRA Training Counselor · NRA & USCCA Certified Instructor · Licensed Firearms Instructor: NY, MD, DC, MA, UT · NY Pistol License Holder Since 1992.
Which NYC handgun rules apply after Mills?
| Rule | Court action and current rule |
|---|---|
| Carry limit | Ruling. The challenge to 38 RCNY § 5-22(a)(7) returns to district court. Today. The rule still applies to Carry and Special Carry licensees. It limits how many handguns you may carry on your person at any one time. |
| 90-day rule | Ruling. The challenge to NYC Administrative Code § 10-302.1(a)–(b) returns to district court. Today. The City’s general limit of one handgun acquisition in a 90-day period still applies, subject to the code’s exceptions. |
| Former cap | Ruling. The claim for past damages arising from former 38 RCNY § 5-25(d)(4) returns to district court. Today. The old absolute cap was removed in 2024. Under the current rule, eligible Carry and Special Carry licensees may request approval for additional listed handguns. |
| Out-of-state cap | Ruling. The panel did not decide this distinct provision. Today. Under 38 RCNY § 5-25(g)(3)(a), the NYPD will not approve a request to add more than one handgun to an out-of-state Non-Resident Carry license issued under § 5-03(b). |
| Other claims | Ruling. The court affirmed dismissal of the fee challenge and the claims it reviewed concerning purchase authorization and registration. Today. Follow current NYPD licensing procedures. The panel resolved authorization and registration on standing grounds and treated the fee claims separately. |
Second Circuit opinion, No. 24-3308 · 38 RCNY § 5-22, Conditions of Issuance · 38 RCNY § 5-25, Handgun Acquisition Requirements · NYC Administrative Code § 10-302.1
What the Second Circuit actually decided
Charles Mills, Craig Sotomayor, and Braden Holliday sued New York City in 2023 over rules governing how people acquire, register, and carry handguns. The district court dismissed the case in December 2024. On November 10, 2026, a unanimous Second Circuit panel led by Judge Reena Raggi, joined by Judges Debra Ann Livingston and Michael Park, vacated part of that judgment and sent three challenges back to the Southern District of New York.
The key dispute was how a court decides whether the Second Amendment covers the conduct in the first place. The lower court treated the ability to carry a single handgun or acquire additional handguns after waiting as enough to dismiss those challenges at the first step. The Second Circuit focused on what the rules actually restrict. Carrying more than one handgun for self-defense falls within the ordinary meaning of bearing arms. A mandatory 90-day interval materially constrains acquisition, which is necessary to keep arms. And the former registration cap, paired with the prohibition on carrying an unlisted handgun, restricted which lawfully owned arms Mills could carry.
That holding resolves an important threshold question. Under New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen, once the text covers the conduct and the law imposes the restriction at issue, the government bears the burden of showing consistency with the Nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation. The panel held that the three claims cleared that threshold. It left constitutionality and any relief for further proceedings.
Second Circuit opinion, No. 24-3308 · Supreme Court opinion in Bruen
Why this direction from the Second Circuit matters
Before Bruen, the Second Circuit’s Kachalsky decision applied intermediate scrutiny to New York’s proper-cause carry requirement. Bruen displaced that approach, as the Second Circuit itself acknowledged in its 2024 Antonyuk opinion. Mills shows what applying the Supreme Court’s approach changes in practice. Judge Rakoff dismissed the three claims at the threshold. The appeals panel held that a temporary or partial restriction can burden protected conduct and sent the claims back for historical review.
A September 30, 2026 decision from the Northern District of New York shows why that appellate direction matters. In Antonyuk, Judge Glenn T. Suddaby questioned the state’s reliance on territorial laws and laws from periods far removed from 1791 and 1868. He recognized that intervening Supreme Court decisions might lead to reversal of some earlier Second Circuit rulings. He nevertheless followed the circuit’s treatment of parks, licensed establishments where alcohol is consumed, theaters, and zoos because he concluded those decisions had not undermined circuit precedent enough to let him depart from it. The plaintiffs appealed that district court ruling.
That is the significance of Mills. A published appellate panel has given district courts a concrete instruction for evaluating rules that constrain the exercise of the right. Once the threshold is met, the court must assess the government’s historical case. Mills addresses handgun acquisition, listing, and carry limits. In the separate Antonyuk appeal, litigants may cite its reasoning about what burdens protected conduct. The Second Circuit’s location-specific precedents and the record in that case will still shape the analysis.
Second Circuit, Antonyuk (2024), slip opinion at 35 · Northern District of New York, September 30, 2026, pp. 46–50 · Antonyuk appeal, No. 26-3152
Why publication matters. The panel’s precedential holdings bind federal district courts in the Second Circuit. A Second Circuit summary order has no precedential effect under Local Rule 32.1.1. A district court opinion can persuade other courts without binding them as circuit precedent. Second Circuit Local Rule 32.1.1.
The Mills timeline
- . Three New York residents sue the City in federal court.
- . The City replaces the rule imposing an absolute two-handgun listing cap. The lawsuit continues.
- . The Southern District of New York enters judgment dismissing the complaint.
- . The permanent NYC licensing amendments take effect, including the revised listing rules.
- . The Second Circuit hears oral argument.
- . The Second Circuit revives three claims, directs further proceedings and affirms the rest of the judgment.
Second Circuit opinion, procedural history · NYC permanent licensing amendments
The district-court docket records the complaint on August 23, 2023. The appellate opinion’s procedural history gives 2022. This timeline follows the complaint entry in the district docket. SDNY docket and complaint entry.
Who brought Mills? Amy Bellantoni’s Second Amendment cases
Amy L. Bellantoni of the Bellantoni Law Firm represented the three plaintiffs on appeal in Mills. Her firm biography identifies her as a former senior assistant district attorney in Rockland County and describes a practice that includes firearm licensing, revocations, seizures, and civil-rights litigation. Her published cases show how appellate advocacy can reopen a constitutional claim and how an as-applied judgment can address the loss of a license.
Mills opinion, counsel listing · Bellantoni Law Firm biography
- Baird v. Bonta (California open carry). Bellantoni argued the 2023 appeal. The Ninth Circuit required the district court to reconsider the preliminary-injunction request under the correct framework. She also argued the later appeal that produced a favorable 2026 panel ruling on restrictions in more populous counties. The Ninth Circuit granted rehearing en banc, so the January 2026 panel opinion cannot be cited as precedent in that circuit. 2023 opinion · 2026 panel opinion · Rehearing order.
- Wysocki v. Nassau County (Long Island license revocations). Bellantoni represented license holders whose firearms were seized and whose licenses were revoked. In July 2026 the Eastern District of New York granted the couple summary judgment on their as-applied Second Amendment claim. The court said they were entitled to the return of their firearms and reinstatement of their licenses and deferred entry of that relief while other claims remained. District court opinion · Public docket mirror.
- Frey v. City of New York (public carry). Bellantoni represented the appellants in a challenge that included Times Square and transit restrictions. The Second Circuit affirmed denial of preliminary relief in 2025. The parties later stipulated to dismissal with prejudice in July 2026. Second Circuit opinion · District court docket mirror.
Three claims, three separate questions
1. The one-handgun carry rule
Section 5-22(a)(7) limits a person with a Carry or Special Carry license to one handgun on their person at any time. This is a simultaneous carry restriction. The license may list more handguns than the person can carry at once. The panel held that carrying more than one for self-defense is conduct covered by the Amendment, so the City must defend the limit under Bruen’s historical test.
2. The 90-day acquisition rule
The City code addresses the transaction from both sides. Subdivision (a) regulates dealer sales or dispositions, and subdivision (b) regulates acquisitions. The panel described the handgun limit as a meaningful constraint because a person’s ability to keep arms depends on being able to acquire them. The opinion concerns the handgun provisions before the court. It does not answer how the City code applies to every transaction, including exemptions, or establish a statewide change.
A recurring acquisition cap is different from the time a licensing agency needs to check an application. The Second Circuit cited the Ninth Circuit’s Nguyen v. Bonta ruling, which struck down California’s former one-firearm-per-30-days law. The panel also acknowledged the First Circuit’s preliminary-injunction ruling in Beckwith v. Frey concerning Maine’s 72-hour wait to take possession of a purchased firearm, and expressly left that kind of rule open. Mills gives challengers a precedent on recurring acquisition caps within the Second Circuit. Courts still have to evaluate the particular delay and its purpose.
Ninth Circuit opinion in Nguyen · Mills, pp. 30–32 and n.15
3. The repealed two-handgun listing cap
In August 2024, while the case was pending, the City replaced the old absolute cap on how many handguns a person could list on a carry license. The permanent amendments took effect January 5, 2025. The panel revived Charles Mills’s challenge to the former rule for retrospective damages. It awarded no damages. The current rule allows eligible Carry and Special Carry licensees to request additional listings, evaluated under the specified safeguarding and waiting-period standards. The distinct one-listing rule for out-of-state Non-Resident Carry licenses remains in the current text.
Second Circuit opinion, No. 24-3308 · 38 RCNY § 5-22, Conditions of Issuance · NYC Administrative Code § 10-302.1 · 38 RCNY § 5-25, Handgun Acquisition Requirements · NYC final firearms licensing rule, effective January 5, 2025
What New York City must show on remand
The City says spacing handgun acquisitions can deter straw buyers from obtaining multiple firearms and diverting them to other people. That is a serious public-safety objective. The open question is whether historical regulations addressed a comparable problem through a comparably burdensome restriction. A law targeting transfers to a particular group, for example, would raise a different historical comparison from a rule that delays the next acquisition across the general licensed population.
The Supreme Court’s United States v. Rahimi decision gives the City room to make a historical analogy without producing an exact period replica. The inquiry looks at why the historical regulation burdened the right and how it did so. For the 90-day rule, that means asking both what problem the proposed historical law addressed and what delay or comparable constraint it actually imposed. The City will need its own historical justification for the one-handgun carry rule and for the former listing cap. The strength of one defense does not decide the other two.
Second Circuit opinion, No. 24-3308 · Supreme Court opinion in Rahimi
An older waiting period or numerical limit could be a candidate if the City identifies one. A late nineteenth-century example would need context showing whether it reflects an established tradition. These are possible arguments to look for in the briefs. Under Rahimi, a sufficiently comparable burden, purpose, and historical tradition could support a ruling upholding a restriction. The district court will evaluate each one separately. Rahimi, 602 U.S. at 691–92 · Three questions for evaluating an analogue.
What counts as historical evidence under Bruen?
The Bill of Rights was ratified on December 15, 1791. The founding generation wrote the Second Amendment in the aftermath of the Revolution, when militia service and the ability to keep arms were familiar parts of public life. The Supreme Court’s Heller opinion also points to Pennsylvania’s 1776 Declaration of Rights, which recognized bearing arms in defense of oneself and the state. That founding-era record helps explain why a broad restriction on ordinary people’s ability to acquire or carry arms calls for a serious historical showing.
National Archives, Bill of Rights · Heller, 554 U.S. 570, 584–85, 595–603
For NYC, the hardest question may be what the historical sources say about limiting ordinary licensed people to one handgun at a time or deliberately spacing out repeat acquisitions. Bruen treats the absence of a distinctly similar regulation as relevant evidence when a modern restriction addresses a problem that also existed in the eighteenth century. Rahimi permits a relevantly similar analogue without an exact match. And Bruen left open whether 1791 or 1868 is the primary reference point when the right is applied to state and local governments. That makes 1791 a central benchmark while leaving room for other evidence a court finds probative.
- What problem did the old law address? A restriction aimed at poaching, for example, has to be evaluated in light of that purpose.
- Whose conduct did it burden, and how? A law targeting a particular danger may impose a different burden from a recurring limit that applies broadly to license holders.
- Was the law representative? Consider its date, its geographic reach, and whether it reflected a widely accepted practice. Bruen discounted late nineteenth-century Texas examples that resembled New York’s special-need rule because the Court found them to be outliers.
Bruen, 597 U.S. 1, 26–30, 34–38, 65–67 · Rahimi, 602 U.S. 680, 691–92
Why invoking the Black Codes is reprehensible
Emancipation ended slavery. In 1865, Southern state legislatures began passing Black Codes to control the lives of newly freed Black Americans. Mississippi used vagrancy laws to punish Black people who lacked the required proof of employment. People who could not pay the resulting fines could be hired out to work. The state also authorized the placement of Black children with white employers as apprentices and restricted freedpeople’s ability to own or carry firearms without a license. These laws reached into families, paychecks, and the ability to defend a home.
National Park Service study, The Black Experience in Natchez · National Archives, records of emancipation and Reconstruction
Disarmament mattered in a period of racial violence. Taking away the ability to defend yourself or your family made it easier for others to enforce that system through intimidation and violence. Congress understood the stakes. Section 14 of the Freedmen’s Bureau Act of 1866 expressly included the constitutional right to bear arms among the protections to be secured equally, regardless of race, color, or previous enslavement.
In Wolford v. Lopez, Hawaii cited an 1865 Louisiana law to defend its requirement of express permission for licensed handgun carry on private property open to the public. The Supreme Court majority identified the Louisiana measure as a Black Code provision that helped disarm Black people and leave them vulnerable to attack. The Court also rejected it as evidence of a national tradition because the law was neither widespread nor widely accepted.
NY Safe’s view. It is reprehensible to invoke a law used to keep freedpeople vulnerable as constitutional authority for restricting a right Congress expressly sought to protect for them. The history belongs in the record because it shows what governments did and what Reconstruction lawmakers fought to remedy. In Mills, the City will have to present its own historical evidence. The lesson from Wolford is to ask whom an old law burdened, why it was enacted, and whether it reflected a genuine American tradition.
Wolford, majority slip opinion pp. 22–24 · McDonald, 561 U.S. 742, 771, 776–79
Why the other claims stayed dismissed
The Second Circuit affirmed the dismissal of the challenges to purchase-authorization and handgun-registration rules it reviewed because the plaintiffs had not adequately alleged the injury required for standing. Those rulings concern who can bring the claims on the allegations presented. Treating them as rulings that the requirements are constitutional would overread the opinion.
The fee analysis was different. The panel found that the plaintiff who said he could not afford the fees had pleaded too few facts to support his individual claim. For the broader challenge, it applied Kwong v. Bloomberg, which upheld the fees at issue, and explained how it reads that precedent after Bruen. The panel distinguished cost-based licensing charges that impose only a marginal burden from fees that are prohibitive or exceed the administrative costs they are meant to cover. A higher fee than another county charges did not establish that NYC’s fees exceeded its costs. The decision leaves existing charges in place and provides no refund.
Second Circuit opinion, No. 24-3308 · Supreme Court opinion in Bruen
Why Mills is progress for a pre-existing right
District of Columbia v. Heller described the Second Amendment as codifying a pre-existing individual right. Bruen recognized that this right extends to public carry for self-defense and placed the historical burden on the government once the text covers the conduct. Mills gives that principle practical force in this circuit. By recognizing that a numerical limit or recurring delay can burden the right even where some exercise remains possible, the panel requires the government to answer for the particular restriction it chose.
There has also been a recent merits ruling with a concrete result. In June 2026, the Supreme Court held in Wolford v. Lopez that Hawaii’s default ban on licensed handgun carry on private property open to the public, absent the owner’s express permission, violated the Second and Fourteenth Amendments. Property owners retained the authority to exclude firearms. Wolford addressed a different rule, but its holding shows what a successful constitutional challenge can produce. Mills advances to the historical inquiry that can lead to such a ruling.
Six days after Mills, on November 16, the Supreme Court declined to hear Novotny v. Moore, a challenge to Maryland’s sensitive-place restrictions. Justice Clarence Thomas agreed with denying review because the petition brought together restrictions that implicated distinct historical traditions. In his separate statement, he expressed serious doubts about the historical basis for many sweeping bans, expressly discussed New York’s restrictions, and urged the Court to consider a narrower case.
The Court’s denial leaves the Fourth Circuit judgment in place. Thomas’s statement gives future challengers a more specific question to bring to court. What history justifies prohibiting carry in this particular kind of place? Mills has the greater immediate legal significance for NYC. It is a published Second Circuit holding requiring historical review of three concrete burdens. Novotny shows that at least one Justice wants a closer look at how that historical inquiry is applied to a different set of laws.
Heller, 554 U.S. 570, 592 · Supreme Court opinion in Bruen · Second Circuit opinion, No. 24-3308 · Supreme Court opinion in Wolford · Justice Thomas’s Novotny statement · Supreme Court docket, No. 25-1324
For the separate rules about where you can carry, see NY Safe’s guide to no-guns signs and sensitive locations.
What NYC license holders should check today
- Check the exact license category. NYC Carry, Special Carry, and an out-of-state Non-Resident Carry license have different listing implications. The single-handgun rule concerns what is carried on the person. The listing rule concerns what is on the license.
- Confirm the handgun is already listed. Use the NYPD License Division’s current authorization and registration process. Before carrying a newly added handgun, confirm that NYPD has entered it on the applicable license and that you have the required license documentation.
- Confirm which acquisition rules apply before a transaction. Start with the current City code and NYPD rule. For an unusual transaction or uncertainty about an exemption, get guidance from the License Division or a New York firearms attorney before moving forward.
Special Carry holders. Section 5-25(h) provides a specific amendment sequence. Follow the purchase-authorization guidelines of the county that issued your underlying Carry license. After the handgun is added to that county license, submit a written amendment request to the NYC License Division. A county listing alone does not establish that the handgun is listed on your NYC Special Carry license. Read § 5-25(h)
38 RCNY § 5-22, Conditions of Issuance · 38 RCNY § 5-25, Handgun Acquisition Requirements · NYC Administrative Code § 10-302.1 · NYPD permits and firearms licensing
What would actually change the rules?
| Docket event | What it means for license holders |
|---|---|
| Mandate | Meaning. Formalizes the appeal’s disposition and returns the case to the district court for further proceedings. Effect. The mandate carrying out this remand does not itself suspend either active rule. |
| Briefs and exhibits | Meaning. Show what each side argues and the sources it relies on. Effect. They can shape the outcome. They do not give license holders relief. |
| Court order | Meaning. May address the merits or grant or deny relief. Effect. Read the exact rule covered, who is protected, when relief takes effect, and whether a stay pauses it. |
| Rule change | Meaning. Changes the legal text on its effective date. Effect. Confirm the adopted language, effective date and applicable license category. |
The next question worth following is what historical evidence the City offers for each rule and how the court evaluates it. A ruling granting relief could still have a limited scope or be stayed pending appeal. Check the operative order before changing your conduct.
Second Circuit opinion, No. 24-3308 · Public Second Circuit docket mirror · Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 41
Where to follow the case. Check Second Circuit No. 24-3308 for the mandate. Once it issues, follow Southern District of New York No. 1:23-cv-07460 (JSR) for scheduling orders, the City’s historical brief, and any ruling on relief. Public mirrors can lag. SDNY instructions for PACER access · Public SDNY docket mirror.
For reporters and readers sharing the ruling
“The Second Amendment does not protect against only permanent or complete deprivations of the right to keep and bear arms.”
NY Safe’s assessment. The Second Circuit settled who has to make the historical case. The burden is on New York City, and the district court must evaluate the justification for each restriction. NYC license holders still follow the current rules while that work happens in court.
What to watch in the City’s filing. Ask whether an example addresses a comparable problem, burdens the same kind of conduct, and reflects a representative practice. Read the three-part historical evidence checklist.
For a quick reference, link directly to the NYC rule comparison or the guide to the next court filings.
Common questions about Mills
Can I carry two handguns on a NYC Carry or Special Carry license after Mills?
No. The November 10 decision did not suspend 38 RCNY § 5-22(a)(7). It still limits Carry and Special Carry licensees to one handgun on their person at a time.
Did Mills end NYC’s 90-day handgun acquisition limit?
No. The panel revived the challenge to the rule and remanded it for further review. The current City code, including its exemptions, still governs covered transactions.
Can I list more than two handguns on my NYC carry license?
Eligible Carry and Special Carry licensees can request approval for additional listings under § 5-25(g)(3). The distinct out-of-state Non-Resident Carry category under § 5-03(b) remains limited to one listed handgun.
Did Justice Thomas’s statement change where I can carry in New York?
No. Thomas wrote separately about a Maryland case the Supreme Court declined to hear. His statement did not alter a New York law or court order.
Does the 90-day issue change the law across New York State?
The claim revived in Mills concerns New York City Administrative Code § 10-302.1(a)–(b) as applied to the handgun provisions at issue. The ruling does not change a separate state statute or a different county’s rules. A later court considering a similar restriction may apply the published panel’s reasoning.
Legal disclaimer. Legal status reviewed November 16, 2026. NY Safe Inc. publishes this article for general educational and informational purposes. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws, licensing rules, and court orders can change. Consult a licensed New York attorney for advice about your circumstances.
Applying for your first New York carry license?
If you’re applying for a New York concealed-carry license, train with NY Safe Inc. Our 16+2 course combines the classroom and live-fire components of New York’s licensing training with an emphasis on safety, de-escalation, and the legal responsibilities that come with a license. Review the course and choose an upcoming date below.
Explore NY Safe’s New York 16+2 concealed-carry course · See what first-time students can expect
Upcoming New York concealed-carry licensing classes
Next Available Classes
Upcoming New York 16+2 CCW Class Dates
Limited to 15 students per class. Seats fill quickly.

No responses yet