NY Gun Law 2026 — NY Safe Inc.
New York Firearm Waiting Period Bill: Why Your NY Pistol License Matters More Than Ever
The New York Senate passed S9338A — a three-calendar-day firearm waiting period bill — on June 3, 2026. It is not law yet. But a permit-holder exception buried in the bill text reveals something every responsible New Yorker should understand: in this state, a pistol license or carry permit is not just a piece of paper.
By Peter Ticali • Founder & Lead Instructor, NY Safe Inc. • June 4, 2026 • 12-min read
Key Takeaway
S9338A is not law yet. The New York Senate passed it 43–18 on June 3, 2026. It is currently in the Assembly Codes Committee, and it still must pass the Assembly and be signed by the Governor before becoming law. But if enacted in its current form, the bill would impose a three-calendar-day waiting period before delivery of a firearm, shotgun, or rifle — while including a license-holder exception that may allow delivery of a pistol, revolver, or semiautomatic rifle to a qualifying license holder upon a NYS NICS “proceed” response, subject to the bill’s exclusions and the final enacted text.
The lesson is not fear. The lesson is preparation. In a state that continuously rewrites firearm rules, lawful training and licensing put responsible citizens in a stronger position every time Albany acts.
Next Available Classes
Upcoming New York 16+2 CCW Class Dates
Limited to 15 students per class. Seats fill quickly.
NY Safe 18-Hour Concealed Carry Training
Practical, civilian-focused training for responsible New Yorkers — the required 16+2 class for Nassau, Suffolk, NYC, Westchester, and beyond.
Small classes. Live fire included. Firearm provided if needed. All experience levels welcome.
What S9338A Would Do
The official Senate bill summary for S9338A describes a three-calendar-day waiting period from the date contact is made with the New York State NICS system before a dealer or other transferor may deliver a firearm, shotgun, or rifle. Sponsored by Senator Michael Gianaris (D-Queens), it passed the Senate 43–18 on June 3, 2026, and was delivered to the Assembly the same day.
This is not about prohibited people. New York already has extensive laws that prevent prohibited individuals from possessing firearms. The new proposal is about timing: whether a lawful purchaser, after passing the required background-check process, must still wait before taking possession of a legally acquired arm.
That is a different — and more constitutionally significant — question. And the license-holder exception written into the bill makes the stakes very concrete for anyone navigating the NY permit process right now.
“A right delayed after eligibility is confirmed is still a right burdened. The question is not whether Albany likes waiting periods. The question is whether the Constitution permits them.”
— Peter Ticali, NY Safe Inc.
The License-Holder Exception: What It Says and What It Means
The bill includes an explicit exception for people who possess a valid license to purchase, carry, or possess a pistol, revolver, or semiautomatic rifle. That language deserves careful reading. It is not a universal exemption from all firearm regulation. It is not a guarantee against future restrictions. But it is a statutory signal from Albany itself about how it views the difference between the general population and people who have already moved through New York’s licensing structure.
New York pistol license holders have already been fingerprinted, investigated, vetted, and approved by a licensing authority. Carry applicants must complete 18 hours of required training, submit applications, provide disclosures, meet statutory eligibility standards, and wait for government review. Licensed citizens have stepped inside the legal framework — voluntarily, deliberately, and on record.
How the Exception Plays Out in Practice
Unlicensed Buyer
Would face a three-calendar-day delay from NYS NICS contact before delivery, unless another exception applies. Process and timelines could change further before next purchase.
Licensed Permit Holder
The Senate-passed bill includes a license-holder exception that may allow delivery of a pistol, revolver, or semiautomatic rifle to a qualifying license holder upon a NYS NICS “proceed” response, subject to exclusions. Being licensed places you in a better statutory position when Albany writes permit-holder exceptions into new rules — as it has done here, and as it may do again.
Permit Applicant (In Process)
Completing the 18-hour training does not by itself make you exempt. But it is the required foundation for applying — and every month you delay is a month you could have been building toward a stronger legal position.
“In New York, a pistol license is not just permission to carry. It is documented proof that you chose training, vetting, and responsibility before the next rule changed.”
— Peter Ticali, NY Safe Inc.
This Is Not Just About Waiting Three Days
Some people will look at S9338A and say, “It’s only three days.” That framing misses the constitutional point entirely — and it misses the human reality.
For a collector, hobbyist, or sport shooter, three days may feel minor. But for a person leaving an abusive relationship, responding to escalating threats, opening a business in a dangerous area, or simply coming to terms with the reality that police cannot be everywhere at once — delay after a cleared background check is not a procedural inconvenience. It is a real burden on a protected right, imposed on a person the government has already confirmed is legally eligible.
The Real Constitutional Question
Once the government has confirmed that a person is not prohibited from owning a firearm, what historical tradition allows the state to delay delivery of a protected arm to that same person? That is the question courts must now answer under Bruen — and it does not disappear because the delay sounds brief to a legislator.
“You do not experience crime statistics. You experience incidents. A city can be safer in aggregate and still dangerous in the moment. Self-defense happens in the moment.”
— Peter Ticali, NY Safe Inc.
The Constitutional Problem After Bruen
The Second Amendment guarantees the right to keep and bear arms. For years, many courts treated that right as second-class — asking whether the government had a sufficient public-safety rationale, and usually deferring to the state. That approach was rejected by the Supreme Court’s modern Second Amendment trilogy.
The Three Cases That Changed the Framework
District of Columbia v. Heller (2008)
The Second Amendment protects an individual right to keep and bear arms for lawful self-defense. Acquiring a firearm is part of exercising that right. A right to keep arms is hollow if the state can block or delay lawful access without historically-grounded justification.
McDonald v. City of Chicago (2010)
The Second Amendment applies against state and local governments through the Fourteenth Amendment. New York is not free to treat it as a federal-only limitation. Albany may regulate, but must do so within constitutional limits.
Courts may not simply balance public-safety interests against Second Amendment burdens. When the Second Amendment’s plain text covers an individual’s conduct, the government must justify the regulation using the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation — not modern policy preferences. That creates a serious problem for any post-clearance waiting period.
The Bruen framework does not mean every waiting-period challenge automatically succeeds. Courts disagree. The Second Circuit has historically been receptive to New York’s gun regulations, and Second Amendment litigation is inherently complex. But the constitutional argument against post-clearance waiting periods is serious and growing — as the New Mexico litigation demonstrates.
“Law-abiding citizens do not train to kill. We train to stop a threat to a life. A three-day delay imposed on people who just proved they belong in the legal framework is not a safeguard. It is a burden on the right itself.”
— Peter Ticali, NY Safe Inc.
What the New Mexico Waiting-Period Case Tells Us
New York is not the only state facing this question. In 2025, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit blocked New Mexico’s seven-day firearm waiting period in litigation involving the NRA and Mountain States Legal Foundation. The court found that challengers were likely to succeed on their Second Amendment claim because the right to keep and bear arms includes the practical ability to acquire arms — and that post-clearance delays burden that right.
The Tenth Circuit also rejected the argument that a modern “cooling-off” rationale automatically satisfies the historical-tradition requirement under Bruen.
What the New Mexico Decision Is — and Is Not — for New York
The Tenth Circuit is not binding on New York courts. New York sits in the Second Circuit, which has historically been more receptive to state gun regulations. The New Mexico ruling is persuasive authority — not controlling precedent. But it directly addresses the same constitutional question S9338A would raise.
There is also a critical detail: New Mexico’s law included a license-holder exception. The Tenth Circuit found that the existence of exceptions did not eliminate the constitutional problem with the broader delay imposed on everyone else. An exception can show that licensing matters without proving that the underlying burden on others is constitutional.
“An exception can show that licensing matters without proving that the underlying burden is constitutional. Both things can be true at the same time.”
— Peter Ticali, NY Safe Inc.
The Exception Proves Why Being Licensed Matters
New York’s firearm rules have changed repeatedly. They changed after Bruen. They changed with the Concealed Carry Improvement Act. They changed with sensitive-location restrictions. They changed with semiautomatic rifle licensing. They changed with ammunition background checks. S9338A is the most recent chapter in a very clear pattern.
Each time Albany changes the rules, the same divide appears: those who are already inside the legal framework, and those who were waiting on the sidelines. The permit-holder exception in S9338A is not the first time licensed citizens have found themselves in a better statutory position — and it will not be the last.
“The more New York regulates, the more valuable lawful training and licensing become. In this state, waiting rarely makes the firearms process easier.”
— Peter Ticali, NY Safe Inc.
This is not an argument that everyone needs to carry. Carrying a firearm in public is a serious personal decision that requires judgment, situational awareness, humility, and continued training. But the licensing process itself carries value independent of whether someone carries daily:
- A NY pistol license matters for lawful possession and home protection.
- A carry license matters when Albany creates permit-holder exceptions in new legislation.
- A completed 18-hour class matters for application readiness — and cannot be retroactively taken after a new rule arrives.
- A careful, documented application matters when a licensing authority reviews your file.
- A semiautomatic rifle license matters for purchase and transfer under current NY law.
In a state that regulates heavily and often, documentation matters. Training matters. Timing matters.
What This Means for Nassau, Suffolk, NYC, and Westchester
New York pistol licensing is not experienced the same way everywhere. Nassau, Suffolk, NYC, and Westchester residents face different procedures, different portals, and different timelines. That is exactly why deferring the decision is a weak strategy in this environment.
Nassau County
Nassau County residents should approach the process with attention to training, documentation, references, and application accuracy. NY Safe’s Nassau County CCW class page is built for residents who want to approach the process carefully and professionally. The class is not just a certificate — it is the foundation for understanding safe handling, legal responsibility, and the genuine weight of carrying in New York.
Suffolk County
Suffolk County residents should pay close attention to which licensing authority applies to their town or city, and what current local procedures require. For many Suffolk residents — especially those considering a carry upgrade — the question is no longer whether training is useful. NY Safe’s Suffolk County CCW class page explains the training step and how to approach the overall process.
New York City
NYC residents and NYC Special Carry applicants face one of the most paperwork-intensive licensing environments in the country. NY Safe’s NYC CCW class page is a solid starting point for understanding the training requirement and overall process. NYC applications require patience, accuracy, and thorough preparation — none of which gets easier the longer you wait.
Westchester County
Westchester applicants should treat the training step as part of a broader licensing strategy rather than a last-minute box to check. NY Safe’s Westchester County CCW class page is designed for residents who want to complete the required training and approach the process with appropriate seriousness.
Premise and Sportsman Permit Holders: The Upgrade Question
If you already hold a premise or sportsman permit and have been considering a full carry upgrade, S9338A illustrates exactly why timing matters. NY Safe’s guide on how to upgrade a NY premise or sportsman permit to full carry explains why the 16+2 class is often the common denominator for people moving toward broader carry authority in New York.
What 2A Supporters Should Do Right Now
S9338A is not law. That means the civic process is still open. New Yorkers who oppose this bill should act respectfully and intelligently — not with social media rage, but with a direct, calm contact to their Assemblymember. Ask for a no vote. Explain that delaying lawful delivery after a person clears the background-check process raises serious Second Amendment concerns under Bruen. Be specific. Be respectful. Be credible.
Support organizations that litigate and advocate for Second Amendment rights. Follow credible updates on official legislative pages, not screenshots. Stay engaged beyond the news cycle. And personally, take the steps you have been putting off.
Reader Action Checklist
- ✓ Verify the current status of S9338A on the official New York Senate bill page.
- ✓ Contact your Assemblymember respectfully and ask for a no vote on any Assembly companion bill.
- ✓ If you plan to apply for a carry permit, complete the required NY 18-hour concealed carry training.
- ✓ If you hold a premise or sportsman permit, evaluate whether a carry upgrade makes sense for your situation.
- ✓ Keep copies of all training records, certificates, application materials, and correspondence.
- ✓ Stay lawful, stay calm, and do not rely on social media for legal decisions. Always verify on official legislative pages before acting.
“For ordinary New Yorkers, the lesson is simple: get informed, get trained, get licensed, and stay engaged. Never give up. Train now. Hope you never need it. Go home.”
— Peter Ticali, NY Safe Inc.
Frequently Asked Questions
These answers reflect the bill’s current Senate-passed form. Always verify current status on official New York legislative pages before making decisions.
Is New York’s firearm waiting-period bill already law?
No. S9338A passed the New York Senate 43–18 on June 3, 2026, and was delivered to the Assembly the same day. It still must pass the Assembly and be signed by the Governor before becoming law. Always verify current status on the official Senate bill page.
What would S9338A actually do?
The bill would require a three-calendar-day waiting period from the date of contact with the New York State NICS system before a dealer or transferor may deliver a firearm, shotgun, or rifle to a purchaser. It includes a license-holder exception that may allow delivery of a pistol, revolver, or semiautomatic rifle to a qualifying license holder upon a NYS NICS “proceed” response, subject to the bill’s exclusions and final enacted text.
Are NY carry permit or pistol license holders exempt from the waiting period?
The Senate-passed version of S9338A includes a license-holder exception that may allow delivery of a pistol, revolver, or semiautomatic rifle to a qualifying license holder upon a NYS NICS “proceed” response, subject to the bill’s exclusions. This should be read against the final enacted text if the bill becomes law — it is not a universal exemption from all firearm regulation, and the Assembly may amend the bill before final passage.
What is the constitutional problem with a post-clearance waiting period?
Under Bruen, the government must justify firearm regulations using the nation’s historical tradition — not modern policy preferences. A post-background-check waiting period burdens the lawful acquisition of a protected arm after the government has already confirmed the buyer is not prohibited. The state must identify a historical tradition that supports that delay, which has proven difficult in other courts applying the Bruen test.
What did the Tenth Circuit say about New Mexico’s waiting period?
In 2025, the Tenth Circuit blocked New Mexico’s seven-day waiting period, finding that challengers were likely to succeed on their Second Amendment claim. The court held that the right to keep and bear arms includes the practical ability to acquire arms. That decision is persuasive authority in New York’s constitutional debates, though it is not binding on Second Circuit courts.
Does the NY 18-hour concealed carry class automatically give me a permit?
No. Completing the 18-hour class does not guarantee a carry permit and does not replace licensing authority review. The class satisfies the required training component for most carry applications in New York. Approval is determined by the licensing authority based on the full application and individual eligibility.
I have a premise or sportsman permit. Should I consider a carry upgrade?
That is a personal decision that depends on your individual circumstances, goals, and local licensing requirements. What S9338A demonstrates is a recurring pattern: licensed citizens are often in a better statutory position when Albany creates permit-holder exceptions. NY Safe’s guide on upgrading a NY premise or sportsman permit to full carry explains the training step and what the process generally involves.
Why does this matter for Nassau and Suffolk residents specifically?
Nassau and Suffolk County residents face different local licensing procedures, portals, and timelines. When statewide rules change, people who have already completed training and begun the licensing process are in a stronger position than those who delayed. NY Safe’s East Meadow training center is convenient for applicants from both counties.
What should 2A supporters do while this bill is in the Assembly?
Contact your Assemblymember respectfully and ask for a no vote. Explain that delaying lawful delivery after a cleared background check raises serious Second Amendment concerns under Bruen. Support organizations that litigate and advocate on these issues. Track the bill on official legislative pages. And complete your own training and licensing before the next rule change.
Does Bruen apply to firearm waiting periods?
Yes, Bruen is the controlling framework for evaluating Second Amendment challenges. When a regulation burdens conduct covered by the Second Amendment’s plain text, the government must demonstrate consistency with the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation. Courts applying that test to post-clearance waiting periods face a historically thin record in support of such delays.
Related NY Safe Resources
Official and Legal Sources
Peter Ticali
Founder & Lead Instructor, NY Safe Inc.
Peter Ticali has held a New York pistol license since 1992. He is an NRA Endowment Life Member; NRA and USCCA Certified Instructor; and a licensed firearms instructor in New York, Maryland, the District of Columbia, Massachusetts, and Utah. An FBI Citizens Academy and SCPD Citizens Academy graduate, he is also a member of FBI InfraGard, NYPD Shield, and SCPD Shield, and serves as Sergeant-at-Arms at Sons of the American Legion Post 833. He teaches the 18-hour New York concealed carry course at Nassau County Rifle & Pistol Range and NY Safe’s East Meadow training center.
NRA Endowment Life Member · NRA & USCCA Certified Instructor · Licensed Firearms Instructor: NY, MD, DC, MA, UT · NY Pistol License Holder Since 1992
Take the Next Step
Get your NY carry permit training done before Albany changes the rules again.
NY Safe’s 18-hour concealed carry class is practical, civilian-focused training for responsible New Yorkers from Nassau, Suffolk, NYC, Westchester, and the greater Northeast. All experience levels welcome. Live fire included. Firearm provided if needed.
Legal Disclaimer
This article is for general educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. NY Safe Inc. is a firearms training organization, not a law firm. Peter Ticali is not an attorney. Firearm laws change frequently; individual facts vary. Bill text and status can change between Senate passage and any final enactment. Always verify the current law and consult a qualified attorney for legal advice specific to your situation. Current judicial interpretations may differ from analysis presented here.
No responses yet